Sélectionner une page

What is striking about it line, while the stanza general, is the « phenomenology away from studying » they supplies

Brand new teetering syntax out of « All the respiration person welfare far beyond »-earliest promoting, then subverting, a coordination between the « delighted like » to the urn therefore the higher guarantee of « people appeal »-will get tall not simply for just what it could determine, but also for the way it behaves. Just as the urn’s ways resists decisive translation, making sure that one line entangles just about any viewer that has learned Keats’s Ode. Practical question out-of story legend (« Just what guys or gods try this type of? ») movements, within this stanza, to the a question of grambiguity has become an average assets out-of urn and you will rhyme, while the problem of interpretation, the average disease out-of Keats’s audio speaker and you may Keats’s audience.

Pleased love!

The new get back regarding concerns inside stanza 4 will likely be just a keen ironic experiences after these types of doublings out of dubious surmise. It hunt deliberately computed to demonstrate the brand new futility away from particular interpretation:

It target of address isn’t the probably practical « Sylvan historian » from stanza step 1 however, a « strange priest, » whoever training (instance his term) is beyond you can once you understand. Neither can there be any odds of discerning an old framework getting which « sacrifice »: origin and termination are going to be an issue of surmise simply:

Issue regarding « what absolutely nothing city » echoes the sooner inquiry getting « what leaf-fring’d legend, » but here brand new configuration away from « or »s issues among those « Nothings » which have existence simply about « ardent journey » from imagination. The latest situation try without an expression and you may, rather, without a sound:

The latest conjunctive « And » rarely breaks brand new move of concern, for this supplies a response that expands interrogative motion into the an undoing of its most site. Inside the stanza 1, brand new urn just like the a « bride-to-be regarding quietness » or a « foster-kid out-of silence » advised an effective haunting indeterminacy, because the paradox away from « unheard melodies » generated one « silence » an elusive religious expansion of voice. Stanza 4 reduces you to possibility to mere emptiness. Like the surroundings when you look at the « Los angeles Belle Dame » where « zero wild birds sing, » right here, too, was an excellent tableau from lack: there is eventually no « historian, » « not a soul to tell/As to why, » as well as the voice away from bold query, wanting to ravish this new urn for the « what » and you may « why, » finds out by itself ironically hitched to help you this lady quiet. The last stanza completes which path: all the questions try engrossed by the target that had thrilled her or him, in addition to urn relapses so you’re able to only « Attic contour »- the brand new « attitude » from « quiet means » one to signals the newest silencing off inquiry.

Indeed, « Fair thinking » relates each other on the loveliness of one’s urn’s art and the fresh new equity, or justice, of the silent appearing

But really even while Keats’s presenter seems to concede this impact, Keats’s rhyme redeems vocabulary from the exploiting their multiplicity away from interpretive indicators. Into the profusion away from puns and you can hues from signification one to enjoy from ode’s last stanza at once speak of and you can enact brand new indeterminacy the brand new ode keeps dramatized during the. Whether your urn’s art withholds their spectral legend, flattening illusory possibility to a merely opaque « Fair feelings! that have brede / Regarding marble boys and you may maidens overwrought, » Keats uses the « read melodies » out of poetry in order to multiply how big is the activity. « Brede, » as an instance, means the standard of the fresh urn’s figured build, but its punning facing « breed » and you may ironic 1 / 2 of-echoes out of « bride » and you may « breathe » discreetly deny brand new « individual hobbies » brand new speaker got estimated onto the urn’s reasonable perceptions. « Overwrought » pertains to similar shadings, having even though it refers to the lapidary quality of the newest https://datingranking.net/tr/jaumo-inceleme/ urn’s structure, additionally criticizes a lifetime in which it’s possible to never ever, never hug. So when a good pun into the over-« raught » (an enthusiastic archaic or Spenserian form of « reached »), it gently mocks the brand new speaker’s previous overreaching to help you idealize the new urn’s tableau, in addition to implicates their look at the newest overwrought figures in advance of him together with his individual overwrought postures out of translation-one sound supplied to chanting, « Ah, pleased, delighted boughs! . . . happier, happier like! » « I discovered my personal Attention therefore overwrought which i had neither Rhyme neither cause inside-thus is actually required to give up, » Keats account of one temper of structure amid Endymion.